Getty ImagesBrandy Melville, the fast-fashion retailer known for its singular sizing, is reportedly closing all fitting rooms across its US locations, a move confirmed by multiple employees. This decision has ignited a firestorm on social media, particularly among the brand’s young female demographic, with many expressing dismay at the restriction.
The absence of fitting rooms presents a significant challenge for shoppers, as one prominent concern voiced online is the difficulty in assessing fit and style without the ability to try items on. “How am I supposed to know if it’s cute on me?!”, a sentiment echoed by many, highlights the frustration. This development comes as the brand, primarily targeting teenage girls, has long faced scrutiny over its “one-size-fits-most” policy, which critics argue caters to a narrow body type and potentially perpetuates unhealthy body image standards.
While Brandy Melville has not issued a public statement regarding the fitting room closures, employees from stores in major cities including New York City, Boston, and Austin have indicated they received directives to permanently dismantle these facilities this week.
For many loyal customers accustomed to the brand’s accessible cotton basics, this change feels like a further step towards alienation. “Stuff fits weird sometimes,” one shopper explained via TikTok. “I would just always try stuff on to see what I wanted, but now I can’t.” Another expressed concerns about the practical implications: “There’s gonna be like a trillion returns.”
Staff at the Greenwich Village location in New York City reported being given minimal explanation for the directive. However, employees in Boston and Austin cited “vandalism” as the reason behind the closures. This explanation appears linked to a trend observed on TikTok earlier this year, where users documented using chewing gum to secure fitting room curtains, which did not always close fully on their own.
An employee from Austin shared that “gum stuck to the curtains” had been a persistent issue, describing the act of attaching gum to walls as a “popular TikTok trend.” This sentiment was underscored by an employee who posted a video of herself scraping gum off the fitting room walls, addressing those responsible: “If you have ever stuck ur gum onto these walls, we have beef.” Another employee documented the removal of fitting room fixtures at a different US store, with the video being posted on Wednesday.
Brandy Melville, a brand established in 1980, commands a polarized response online. Its business practices and image have been subject to extensive criticism, notably in the 2024 HBO documentary “Brandy Hellville & The Cult of Fast Fashion,” which leveled accusations of promoting eating disorders and the sexualization of its young employees. The company has yet to officially respond to these allegations or its ongoing controversy surrounding its exclusive sizing model.
Business Style Takeaway: The fitting room closures at Brandy Melville underscore a growing tension between brand identity and consumer experience in the digital age. For businesses, this serves as a critical reminder that while marketing can create allure, operational choices that alienate core demographics can lead to significant backlash and potentially impact long-term brand loyalty and market position.
Details can be found on the website : www.bbc.com